Same AI, same 57 real drafts. Each square is one answer. Orange means it did what the writer needed.
Three drafts from the test, with both answers exactly as the AI wrote them.
Product shot of my new coffee grinder.
Why it’s wrong: it sent the draft back almost unchanged: no lighting, background or angle.
product shot of my new coffee grinder, centred on a clean neutral backdrop, soft diffused studio light from the side, gentle soft shadow beneath, eye-level camera angle, sharp focus on the grinder, minimal and uncluttered, photorealistic
I don't see any text to improve yet. Could you paste the text you'd like me to work on?
Why it’s wrong: it said there was no text to improve, and asked for some.
nope, that won't work, the schema changed last week
Wide shot of a lone lighthouse standing against a violent storm at sea, dramatic and moody. Towering waves crash against its rocky base, sheets of rain sweep across the scene, and dark, churning clouds fill the sky. The beam of light cuts through the gloom. No people, just the lighthouse and the raging elements.
Why it’s wrong: it left “wide” and “no people” as words, so Midjourney ignores them (no --ar or --no).
Wide shot of a lighthouse in a storm, moody and atmospheric, the lighthouse small against the frame so the scale of the storm carries the image, with no people anywhere in the scene, photorealistic, cinematic composition, muted cool palette with dramatic low light --ar 16:9 --no people
The fine print: a half-right answer counts as half. We never tweak Polido using these 57 drafts. With this many drafts, gaps under about 10% can be luck; the ones above are far bigger.